| Platinum | Mama's Famous Pizza & Grill |
| Gold | Biaggio Pizzeria & Restaurant |
| Silver | Palumbo Pizza & Subs |
| Bronze | Salvatore Ruffino's |
| Top Pick | Da Vinci's |
| Top Pick | Delicioso Pizza & Subs |
| Top Pick | Dino's Pizzateria |
| Top Pick | Little Sal's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Mario's Pizza Cafè |
| Top Pick | Nicks Bistro and Pizzaria |